"
I saw this in D3. Absolutely NOT
Come on dude.
You have nothing but "Diablo 3 bad" to offer.
I'm tired of the claims that PoE would magically fail if the trade site was automated to work like an AH without the tedious player interaction that adds nothing but tedium.
|
Posté parMordgier#6997le 10 janv. 2025 14:34:53
|
"
Yes, they will. The average player will just play the game and enjoy it for what it is. They will pick up items and use them and try to learn how to make a good character. They'll struggle at Geonor until someone tells them to check vendors for some cold resistance and once they get some they'll blast him and win and continue playing the game.
With an AH the solution will always just be to go buy items on the auction house. You will never have to look for items, unless the inflation is so bad that the AH will not be usable by anyone regardless (which probably will be the case). The balance of the game is going to be completely destroyed by the fact that everyone will have access to upgrades in just a few button clicks with no friction attached. Orbs will never ever be used for crafting because it will be meaningless compared to just putting items up on the AH and buying perfect upgrades.
You people simply do not understand game design at all and I am glad that GGG still has some sense when it comes to this.
You're deluded. The average player will hate everything about this game the way it is right now.
Going to the AH to buy upgrades is exactly what 99% of the playerbase has done since the day the trade site went live. This game is entirely balanced and built around trade. You can lie to yourself all you want, but you can't lie to me and expect me to believe you.
Dernière édition par maquino85#7657, le 10 janv. 2025 14:36:39
|
Posté parmaquino85#7657le 10 janv. 2025 14:35:05
|
"
Come on dude.
You have nothing but "Diablo 3 bad" to offer.
I don't understand you brother. I don't think D3 is bad, or AH in D3 was bad. It's in your head.
On Probation Any%
|
Posté parDxt44#4050le 10 janv. 2025 14:36:10
|
"
Good deals on trades are already sniped by API bots.
An AH isn't going to create any problems that don't already exist.
They will solve the problem of thousands of fake lowball listings that are there just to trap newbies into underpricing their wares.
It's not going to create a new problem, but it will make the existing problem worse by speeding up the amount of trades that can happen at any given time.
|
Posté parzergy_eggy#4745le 10 janv. 2025 14:38:51
|
"
"
Come on dude.
You have nothing but "Diablo 3 bad" to offer.
I don't understand you brother. I don't think D3 is bad, or AH in D3 was bad. It's in your head.
Then post anything besides "Diablo 3"
This isn't about Diablo 3.
The AH in Diablo 3 wasn't even bad - itemization was. The AH ended up the only way to actually get any gear at all - and with $ - because anything worth selling sold for $ - because obviously right? Why would you sell a fancy ring for game currency rather than $50?
That's a unique issue to how the AH was setup in D3 and had NOTHING to do with the AH itself.
|
Posté parMordgier#6997le 10 janv. 2025 14:38:55
|
"
"
Good deals on trades are already sniped by API bots.
An AH isn't going to create any problems that don't already exist.
They will solve the problem of thousands of fake lowball listings that are there just to trap newbies into underpricing their wares.
It's not going to create a new problem, but it will make the existing problem worse by speeding up the amount of trades that can happen at any given time.
Great - what is the existing problem since we agree that it's not the AH.
Lets solve that?
|
Posté parMordgier#6997le 10 janv. 2025 14:39:39
|
"
"
Good deals on trades are already sniped by API bots.
An AH isn't going to create any problems that don't already exist.
They will solve the problem of thousands of fake lowball listings that are there just to trap newbies into underpricing their wares.
It's not going to create a new problem, but it will make the existing problem worse by speeding up the amount of trades that can happen at any given time.
You forgot to add "I assume, because I have absolutely zero evidence that backs up my claim" to your statement.
|
Posté parmaquino85#7657le 10 janv. 2025 14:40:01
|
"
Then post anything besides "Diablo 3"
This isn't about Diablo 3.
The AH in Diablo 3 wasn't even bad - itemization was. The AH ended up the only way to actually get any gear at all - and with $ - because anything worth selling sold for $ - because obviously right? Why would you sell a fancy ring for game currency rather than $50?
That's a unique issue to how the AH was setup in D3 and had NOTHING to do with the AH itself.
Why are you quoting me? You again speak with yourself. Dude, stop, take some break
On Probation Any%
|
Posté parDxt44#4050le 10 janv. 2025 14:40:18
|
"
"
"
Good deals on trades are already sniped by API bots.
An AH isn't going to create any problems that don't already exist.
They will solve the problem of thousands of fake lowball listings that are there just to trap newbies into underpricing their wares.
It's not going to create a new problem, but it will make the existing problem worse by speeding up the amount of trades that can happen at any given time.
You forgot to add "I assume, because I have absolutely zero evidence that backs up my claim" to your statement.
I'd be happy to have you list the 'problems' the AH would add.
You're more than welcome to post the "manifesto" if you like, but then you'd also have to read through the pages where it's been beaten to death for how wrong it was....
|
Posté parMordgier#6997le 10 janv. 2025 14:42:31
|
"
I'm curious, if they somehow integrated the website slightly more making it so when you click the "whisper player" button it automatically opens the trade window, slots the item and you can now buy it for the listed price.
Would this just make everyone feel better?
Sounds good to me... if I understood correctly what you describe.
All I want from trade is to:
- be fully integrated into the game
- not be reliant on seller being online/not AFK/not busy with something else
- have instant buyout (to get rid of price fixers/checkers more than anything else).
That is all.
I believe this would save a lot of time and frustration. But then, I trade very little, and personally couldn't care less about the economy.
|
Posté parTristavel#6889le 10 janv. 2025 14:42:53
|
