Cant decide which glove piece I should wear

Hello,

Im playing a rf inq and I always had this glove Im currently wearing.

Now I bought a fractured glove (max life 88) and I used one essence which rolled pretty well in my opinion:
Base: energy 21
-88 max Life
-60 dex
-38.8 life reg
-49 max mana
-35% chaos res

But im not sure if I should replace my old glove
Base: armor 89
-+2 aoe gem
- 29 str
- 1-2 extra dmg
- 68 max life
- 45 % fire res ( im at 153% fire res)
- 10% bigger aoe